You defended yourself, or someone you love did, and the police made an arrest anyway. That happens often in Okaloosa, Walton, and Santa Rosa Counties. Officers arrive at a chaotic scene and usually leave the question of self-defense for the courts to answer.
Florida gives you a way to raise that question early. A stand your ground immunity hearing is a pretrial hearing where a judge decides whether your use of force was legally justified. If the judge rules in your favor, the court dismisses the case before a jury ever hears it.
I’m T.S. Lupella. Over more than 20 years and thousands of court appearances, including murder trials, I have seen how much these hearings can shape a case. Here is how they work and what you should know if you face charges after defending yourself.
What Stand Your Ground Immunity Means in Florida
Florida Statute 776.032 gives a person who lawfully uses or threatens force immunity from criminal prosecution and from civil lawsuits. Immunity goes beyond a typical defense because it means the case should never reach trial.
The protection applies when your force was justified under Florida’s self-defense laws. In general, you must have reasonably believed force was necessary to stop an imminent threat, and the force you used must fit that threat. Deadly force requires a reasonable belief that you faced death, great bodily harm, or a forcible felony. You also have no duty to retreat if you were in a place you had a right to be and were not engaged in criminal activity.
These hearings come up in many kinds of cases, from a fight outside a bar on Okaloosa Island to a dispute between neighbors in Crestview. Our battery and violent crimes defense page covers the charges that most often lead to a self-defense claim.
How a Stand Your Ground Hearing Starts
The process begins when your defense attorney files a pretrial motion to dismiss. The motion lays out what happened and why those facts meet the legal test for justified force. Courts call this a prima facie claim.
The bar for a prima facie claim is fairly low. In Jefferson v. State, a Florida appeals court held that the defense only has to raise the claim, not prove it, to shift the burden to the State. Even so, the facts in the motion need real support, so we build the record carefully before we file.
Timing matters. The evidence that wins these hearings, such as surveillance video, 911 recordings, and witness statements, can disappear fast. If you were arrested in Fort Walton Beach or anywhere in Okaloosa County after defending yourself, calling Lupella & Rehr early gives us time to collect that evidence while it still exists.
Who Has the Burden of Proof at a Stand Your Ground Hearing
The State carries the burden. Once the defense raises a prima facie claim, prosecutors must prove by clear and convincing evidence that you are not entitled to immunity.
Before 2017, the defendant had to prove entitlement to immunity. The Legislature changed the statute that year, and in Love v. State the Florida Supreme Court confirmed that the new burden applies to every immunity hearing held after the change took effect.
Clear and convincing evidence is a demanding standard. It sits above the “more likely than not” standard used in most civil cases and below the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard used at trial. When the evidence is close or conflicting, this standard favors you.
What Happens Inside the Courtroom
A judge decides the motion without a jury. Both sides can call witnesses, play recordings, and introduce evidence. In most cases, the judge looks closely at:
- What witnesses saw and heard, and how consistent their accounts are
- 911 calls, body camera footage, and surveillance or cell phone video
- Injuries to everyone involved, along with medical records
- Whether anyone had a weapon, and who had it
- Whether the force you used was reasonable for the threat you faced
You do not have to testify. The court in Jefferson made clear that a judge cannot force a defendant to take the stand just to raise the claim. Whether you should testify is a decision we make together after reviewing the evidence.
Here is a simple example. Two men argue outside a restaurant in Destin. One swings a bottle, and the other punches him and breaks his jaw. Police arrest the man who threw the punch. At the hearing, a server’s phone video shows the bottle swing came first. If the State cannot prove by clear and convincing evidence that the punch was unjustified, the judge must dismiss the case.
Stand Your Ground Hearing vs. Jury Trial
| Immunity Hearing | Jury Trial | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | A judge | A jury |
| When it happens | Before trial | After the hearing, if the case continues |
| The State’s burden | Clear and convincing evidence that your force was not justified | Proof beyond a reasonable doubt that you did not act in lawful self-defense |
| If you win | Charges dismissed, with immunity from a civil suit for the same incident | A not guilty verdict |
| If you lose | The case moves toward trial, and you can still claim self-defense | Sentencing or an appeal |
What Happens If the Judge Grants or Denies Immunity
If the judge grants immunity, the court dismisses the charges. The State can appeal, but it cannot prosecute unless a higher court reverses the ruling. Immunity also protects you from a civil lawsuit over the same incident.
If the judge denies immunity, you still have options. You can argue self-defense at trial, where the State must disprove it beyond a reasonable doubt. Before trial, your attorney can also ask the First District Court of Appeal, which reviews cases from Okaloosa, Walton, and Santa Rosa Counties, to reverse the denial through a petition for a writ of prohibition.
We see these claims most often in our homicide defense and assault defense cases. Even when a judge denies the motion, the hearing gives us a sworn record of what the State’s witnesses said, which often proves valuable at trial.
How a Former Prosecutor Shapes Our Stand Your Ground Strategy
My partner, David Rehr, spent years as a prosecutor with the Office of the State Attorney in Okaloosa County. He knows how prosecutors prepare to challenge an immunity claim because he did that work himself.
Prosecutors tend to attack these claims in predictable ways. They look for a gap in time between the threat and the response, for conflicts between the defendant’s statements and the evidence, and for signs that the defendant started the confrontation. David’s experience helps us anticipate those arguments and answer them.
If police want to talk to you about an incident where you defended yourself, contact Lupella & Rehr at (850) 362-6655 before you give a statement. What you say in those first hours often becomes the State’s main evidence at the hearing.
Self-Defense Cases Involving Service Members Near Eglin and Hurlburt
Many of our clients serve at Eglin Air Force Base or Hurlburt Field. If you are on active duty, two systems may review the same incident. A civilian judge decides whether Florida immunity applies, while your command may take separate administrative or UCMJ action. Where the incident happened also matters, since some areas on base fall under federal jurisdiction. Our page for military personnel who have been arrested explains how a civilian charge can affect your career.
Stand Your Ground Immunity Hearing FAQs
Do I have to testify at a stand your ground hearing?
No. Florida courts have held that a defendant does not have to testify to raise an immunity claim. Your attorney can support the claim through other witnesses, recordings, and physical evidence.
Can I still claim self-defense at trial if the judge denies immunity?
Yes. A denial at the hearing doesn’t prevent you from arguing self-defense to a jury. At trial, the State must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you did not act in lawful self-defense.
Does stand your ground apply in domestic violence cases?
It can. Self-defense claims come up often in domestic violence arrests, especially when both people have injuries and police must decide who the primary aggressor was. Our domestic violence defense page explains how these cases move through the local courts.
Can I use stand your ground if I had a gun with me?
Possibly. A firearm alone doesn’t defeat a self-defense claim, and Florida allows eligible adults to carry a concealed firearm without a license. However, if you were not legally allowed to have the gun, that may affect whether you had a duty to retreat. Pointing or displaying a firearm can also lead to separate charges, such as improper exhibition of a weapon.
How soon should I talk to a lawyer about a stand your ground defense?
As soon as possible, and ideally before you speak with investigators. Early action lets your attorney preserve video and find witnesses while the evidence is fresh.
Talk to a Fort Walton Beach Defense Team Before Your Hearing
If you were arrested after defending yourself, you need a defense team that knows how these hearings unfold in Okaloosa, Walton, and Santa Rosa County courtrooms. Lupella & Rehr has offices in Fort Walton Beach, Destin, Crestview, and DeFuniak Springs. Call us today at (850) 362-6655 to schedule a confidential consultation and talk through your options.
